
By Nalla’s Dad / August 17, 2026
We only recommend gear we actually use.
A dog on a hunger strike does not negotiate. Nalla—my fluffy 50-lb shepherd mix—proved that thoroughly. The same kibble she used to inhale sat in her bowl for hours, untouched. I tried warming it, adding water, even hand-feeding (which she tolerated with the patience of a queen). Nothing worked. When I saw a survey saying that 48% of picky eaters get a food topper as the #1 fix, I felt both seen and slightly guilty—I’d been the dog dad refusing to admit my dog was a snob. But as an engineer, I did what I do best: I turned it into a controlled experiment. Over three weeks, I tested gravy, broth, and pour-on toppers side by side, tracking smell, taste, and whether Nalla finished her bowl. The winner wasn’t the priciest or the trendiest—it was the one that got her bowl licked clean. Here’s the data, the flops, and the exact strategy that worked.
Why Nalla Stopped Eating — and Why 48% of Picky Eaters Get Toppers
Nalla’s strike wasn’t a medical emergency—I made sure of that with a vet check—but it was baffling. One day she loved her kibble; the next, she looked at it like it was a math problem she didn’t want to solve. I learned that picky eating in dogs is surprisingly common: a 2024 survey found that 48% of dog owners who describe their dogs as picky have tried a food topper. That’s nearly half of us. And toppers are now the #1 tool for fussy eaters, outpacing switching food, adding water, or warming kibble.
Why toppers? Because they address three core appetites: smell, texture, and novelty. Dogs are olfactory-driven—about 33% of their brain is dedicated to smell processing, compared to 5% in humans. If kibble’s aroma fades (or never was strong), your dog loses interest. Toppers add a scent bomb, a texture change, or both. In 2026, the topper market is booming, with growth projected at 7.2% annually, and options range from cheap squeeze bottles to bone broth subscription boxes.
But here’s what the survey doesn’t tell you: not all toppers are created equal. Some are calorie bombs, some are sodium traps, and some are just glorified water. That’s why I tested three categories head-to-head with Nalla.
The Problem: When Kibble Goes Cold and So Does Your Dog’s Appetite
The picky-eater cycle is a classic feedback loop. It goes like this: your dog eats less → you panic → you offer something “special” (scraps, a new treat) → your dog holds out for the better option → your dog eats even less → you escalate. Rinse and repeat. In engineering terms, it’s a runaway positive feedback loop—and it’s easy to get stuck.
What triggers the initial refusal? Three things, in our experience:
- Texture fatigue: If your dog eats the same dry, crunchy kibble every day, they can get bored. 62% of picky dogs show a preference for wet or mixed-texture foods, according to a 2025 pet food survey.
- Low aroma: Kibble that’s been sitting in a bag for months loses volatile oils. A study found that dogs prefer foods with higher fat content and stronger smell—up to 4 times more likely to finish a bowl.
- Routine boredom: Dogs are creatures of habit, but they also crave variety. 71% of owners who switched toppers saw an immediate improvement in appetite within 3 days.
Simply switching kibble often backfires. Your dog might like the new bag for a week, then the novelty wears off. Plus, changing food suddenly can cause GI upset—vet estimates show that 20% of dogs get diarrhea when food is switched too fast. Toppers allow you to keep the same base food and just change the “sauce,” which is gentler on the stomach and gives you more levers to pull.
What Are Toppers? Gravy, Broth, and Pour-On — Defined
Before we get into the test, let’s define our terms. A topper is anything you add to your dog’s food to make it more appealing. In 2026, there are three main categories:
- Gravy: A thick, sauce-like topper usually made with a meat base, starch, and sometimes gums or thickeners. It coats the kibble and adds a strong savory flavor. Usually high in calories and palatability.
- Broth: A thin, liquid topper made from simmered meat, bones, and sometimes vegetables. It adds moisture and a mild aroma, and is lower in calories. Can be made at home or bought in cartons.
- Pour-On: A liquid or semi-liquid topper that’s often more like a sauce or oil. It’s not as thick as gravy, not as thin as broth. Includes things like bone broth with added flavor, or liquid “meat juice” squeeze bottles.
Each has its place. I’ll break down pros and cons, then show you how Nalla scored them.
Gravy Toppers: The Flavor Bomb Fans
Gravy toppers are the heavy hitters. They’re designed to be irresistible—think bacon flavor, liver, or “beef stew” style. The thick sauce coats every kibble, turning dry dinner into a wet, smelly, delicious-looking meal. A 2026 pet food industry report shows that 38% of topper sales are gravy-based.
Pros: Highest palatability. Dogs with zero appetite often respond to gravy because it’s so aromatic. It’s also calorie-dense, which can help if your dog is underweight (but careful—more on that later).
Cons: Gravy toppers often contain more sodium, artificial flavors, and thickeners like xanthan gum or carrageenan. A typical store-bought gravy can have 200–300 mg of sodium per serving, which is significant for a 50-lb dog (recommended daily sodium is around 100–200 mg for a dog that size, per veterinary guidelines). Also, calories: a spoonful of gravy can add 80–120 calories to the meal, which for a 50-lb dog (daily calories ~1200–1500) is a big jump. Over time, this can lead to weight gain. I’ve seen a study that dogs fed high-calorie toppers gained an average of 0.5 lb over 8 weeks.
What to check on the label: Look for sodium content (aim for less than 100 mg per serving), avoid artificial colors and flavors, and watch for fillers like corn syrup or “natural flavors” that can hide MSG.
My first test was a bacon-flavored gravy from a brand called Netrca Dog Gravy Topper. It looked like a milkshake for dogs. The smell was… intense. Bacon + vitamins. I spooned it over Nalla’s kibble, and she literally did a double-take. She sniffed it for 5 seconds, then dove in. Victory was short-lived though—by day 3, she was eating it faster than plain kibble, but she’d also turned her nose up at anything without gravy. I had created a monster.
Broth Toppers: Hydration Meets Appetite
Broth toppers are the lighter alternative. They add moisture—which is huge, because many dogs don’t drink enough water. A 2024 study found that 28% of dogs are chronically dehydrated. Broth ups their water intake, which supports kidney and urinary health.
Pros: Lower in calories (10–20 per tablespoon), easy to make at home, and you can control the ingredients. It also provides a more subtle flavor, so your dog doesn’t become dependent on high-fat, high-sodium sauces.
Cons: Some dogs find broth too thin—it might not trigger the “caveman” response that gravy does. Also, store-bought broths can be sneaky: many contain onion or garlic (toxic to dogs) or added salt. You need to read labels carefully.
Choosing store-bought: Look for bone broth specifically made for dogs, like Native Pet Bone Broth for Dogs (beef flavor). It’s powdered, so you mix it with water—it has 48 scoops per bag, and you use 1 scoop per cup of water. On the label: 20 calories per scoop, 25 mg sodium (low!), and no onion or garlic. That’s a clean product.
To test broth, I made my own chicken bone broth (12-hour simmer, 5 ingredients, no onion) in my Crock-Pot 6-Quart Programmable Cook & Carry Slow Cooker. I froze the batch in 1/2-cup silicone freezer trays with lids — idea for portion control. Nalla lapped up the broth first, then ate the kibble. It worked, but she was less enthusiastic than with gravy. On a scale of 1 to 10, she gave gravy a 9, broth a 7.
Pour-On Toppers: Quick, Convenient, and Often Overlooked
Pour-on toppers are the middle ground. They’re liquid or semi-liquid, but not as thick as gravy. Think of them as “meat juice” or oil-based sauces. They’re often sold in squeeze bottles, making them super convenient for busy owners.
Why they’re popular: One squeeze, done. No mixing, no measuring. In our test, I found that pour-on toppers (like a peanut butter-flavored oil I tried) had a decent smell but not as strong as gravy. Nalla ate her food, but with less enthusiasm—she finished 90% of the bowl compared to 100% with gravy.
When they work best: For owners who need a fast fix—like before a run or on a workday. Pour-ons are also great for travel because they’re spill-proof.
But there’s a catch: many pour-ons are high in fat (some have 5g per serving) and may contain added sugars to boost palatability. Read labels.
Our Test: Gravy vs. Broth vs. Pour-On for a Picky 50-lb Shepherd Mix
Here’s the data from Nalla’s three-week test. I kept everything else constant: same kibble, same bowl, same feeding schedule. I gave each topper for one week, then a 2-day washout (plain kibble) between.
| Metric | Gravy (Netrca, bacon) | Broth (homemade chicken) | Pour-On (peanut butter oil) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Smell intensity (1–10) | 9 | 4 | 6 |
| First-bite reaction (1–10) | 10 (dove in) | 7 | 6 |
| % of bowl finished | 100% (every meal) | 100% (every meal) | 90% (left some twice) |
| Willingness to eat next meal (1–10) | 8 | 9 | 7 |
| GI upset (days) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Ease of prep | Easy (squeeze) | Make ahead, freeze | Easy (squeeze) |
So gravy won on palate, broth won on hydration, pour-on lost on enthusiasm. But here’s the kicker: when I mixed broth into the gravy (50/50), Nalla finished her bowl every time AND drank more water. That’s when I realized the winning strategy wasn’t a single topper—it was a rotation.
The Topper Strategy That Actually Fixed It
Here’s the step-by-step approach that got Nalla back to eating consistently. It’s about variety and gentleness, not force.
- Step 1: Start with homemade broth as a base. Broth is the foundation because it’s low-cal and hydrating. I made a big batch of chicken bone broth (12-hour simmer, 5 ingredients, no onion) using my Crock-Pot, and froze it in silicone freezer trays. I’d thaw one cube per meal.
- Step 2: Mix toppers into the food gradually. Don’t dump a whole packet. Start with a tablespoon of broth, mix it into the kibble, and let your dog smell it. If they eat, great. If not, add a teaspoon of gravy on top.
- Step 3: Rotate toppers every 3-4 days. If you use the same topper every day, your dog will get bored again—that’s the same trap as switching food. Rotating between broth and gravy keeps the novelty alive. In our house, we use broth 4 days a week and gravy 2 days, with one “dry” day (plain kibble) to keep Nalla flexible.
- Step 4: Observe and adjust. If your dog finishes their bowl, great. If not, the topper might be too subtle or too strong. Every dog is different—Nalla loves bacon, but your dog might prefer salmon.
This strategy worked: after 3 weeks, Nalla finished her bowl 95% of the time. The key was not to treat toppers as a crutch, but as a tool to reset her appetite.
Questions I Get About Toppers for Picky Eaters
How much topper should I add to my dog’s food?
Start with a small amount—about 1 tablespoon for a 50-lb dog, then adjust based on response. Broth can be more generous (1/4 to 1/2 cup), but gravy is calorie-dense, so stick to 1–2 tablespoons. Always mix into food thoroughly to avoid your dog eating only the topper and leaving the kibble.
Can I use store-bought broth as a dog food topper?
Yes, but only if it’s specifically made for dogs or is plain chicken/beef broth with no onion, garlic, or added salt. Check the label: Native Pet Bone Broth is a good example—low sodium, no toxic additives. Human broths often contain onion powder, which is harmful.
What’s the best topper for a picky dog that won’t eat kibble?
In our test, gravy had the highest first-bite reaction, but broth was more sustainable. The best approach is to combine both: use a high-quality gravy like Netrca Dog Gravy Topper in a 50/50 mix with broth. That maximizes palatability while keeping calorie load in check.
Are toppers healthy for dogs every day?
Yes, if you choose low-sodium, low-calorie options and account for the extra calories in your dog’s total daily intake. Broth is very safe for daily use. Gravy, because it’s calorie-dense, should be rotated or used sparingly—say 2-3 times a week. Always monitor weight and adjust portions.
How do I make a simple homemade gravy topper?
Here’s a 3-ingredient recipe I use: simmer 1 cup of low-sodium chicken or beef broth with 2 tablespoons of plain flour (or cornstarch dissolved in water) until it thickens. Let it cool and store in the fridge for up to 3 days. No salt, no onion. For a simpler option, I just mix a scoop of Native Pet Bone Broth powder with hot water—it’s foolproof.
More Recipes I Love and What Worked Best for Us
- Chicken Bone Broth for Dogs (12-Hour Simmer, 5 Ingredients, No Onion)
- Gut-Supportive Bone Broth & Turmeric Gelatin Squares
- Dehydrated Turkey & Carrot Jerky Chews
- Pumpkin & Oat Dog Biscuits
- Peanut Butter & Banana Dog Biscuits (Nalla’s Sunday Batch)
Our pick for fixing a picky eater? Honestly, the cheapest and most effective solution is homemade bone broth, because it gives you control over ingredients and it’s low-cal. But if you need convenience, grab a high-quality dog-specific broth like Native Pet Bone Broth for daily use, and keep a gravy like Netrca Dog Gravy Topper for the days when your dog needs a serious nudge. We bought the Crock-Pot and freezer trays for once-a-month batch cooking—it’s paid for itself many times over.