
By Nalla’s Dad | August 14, 2026
We only recommend gear we actually use.
There is no dignified way to say this: Nalla—my 50-lb fluffy shepherd mix—had the runny poops. At first, I figured it was just a bad batch of treats. But after a week of consistency that would make a software engineer weep (and a poop-scooping routine that felt like a second job), I knew I had to stop guessing and start testing. As an engineer, I love data. As a dog dad, I love a firm stool. So I decided to run a controlled experiment: one week of pumpkin, one week of sweet potato, tracking everything from stool quality to pickiness. Here’s what I learned—and what might help your dog’s belly too.
The Runny Poop Saga: How This Test Started
It began with a normal Tuesday walk. Nalla squatted, and what came out was… not normal. It was the kind of soft, shapeless mess that makes you double-check the expiration date on the kibble bag. Over the next few days, it didn’t improve. I switched to bland rice and boiled chicken (per the usual advice), but as soon as I reintroduced her regular food, the tummy troubles returned.
I could have just called the vet—and honestly, if it had gone past two weeks, I would have. But I also know that many digestive upsets in healthy adult dogs respond to a simple fiber boost. The question was: which fiber? Everyone online seemed to be shouting either “pumpkin!” or “sweet potato!”—and both seemed credible. So I did what any engineer would do: I set up a controlled, reproducible test. Two weeks, two ingredients, a poop chart, and a very patient dog.
This post isn’t a vet’s opinion (I’m not one). It’s a real-world, hands-on experiment with my own dog, and I’ll share the raw data and what surprised me.
Why Everyone Is Suddenly Asking This Question
If you’ve been on social media lately, you’ve likely seen the viral vet videos comparing pumpkin and sweet potato for dogs. Some claim pumpkin is the only way; others swear sweet potato is better for digestion. On Quora, Reddit, and dog owner forums, the question “pumpkin vs sweet potato for dog digestion” has become a top debate. And then there’s Evanger’s canned sweet potato, which some owners swear by as a pumpkin alternative—fueling the confusion even more.
Part of the problem is that both ingredients are rich in fiber and are often lumped together as “same thing, different color.” But nutritionally, they’re quite different, and those differences matter. Another factor is that commercial dog foods often use one or the other as a “grain-free” filler, so owners naturally wonder which one is actually helping their dog’s gut.
As a data-driven dog owner, I wanted to cut through the anecdotes. Here’s the nutrition breakdown that got me started.
Pumpkin vs Sweet Potato: The Nutrition Breakdown
First, let’s talk fiber—the hero of digestive health. Fiber comes in two kinds: soluble (dissolves in water, feeds gut bacteria, helps firm up loose stool) and insoluble (adds bulk, helps move things along).
Pumpkin (canned, plain, unsweetened): About 3–4% fiber by weight (based on USDA data for canned pumpkin). That’s roughly 2–3 grams of fiber per 100g. Most of that fiber is soluble, which is why pumpkin is often recommended for both diarrhea and constipation—it absorbs excess water in the gut and adds gentle bulk. It’s also low in calories: about 26–30 calories per 100g. Plus, it’s packed with vitamin A (over 170% of a dog’s daily need per 100g) and some vitamin C, potassium, and iron.
Sweet potato (cooked, plain): Slightly higher in calories—about 90 calories per 100g—and has about 3g of fiber per 100g. The fiber mix is more balanced between soluble and insoluble, which can be better for dogs with occasional constipation. Sweet potato is also a great source of vitamin A (though the type is beta-carotene, which dogs convert less efficiently than humans), plus B vitamins, vitamin C, and potassium. It’s higher in sugar (about 4-5g per 100g) compared to pumpkin (about 3g), so it’s not ideal for diabetic dogs.
In my engineer’s head: pumpkin = targeted soluble-fiber tool for diarrhea. Sweet potato = gentler, balanced-fiber food that also adds more calories. Both are safe for most dogs in moderation, but they’re not interchangeable. And that’s why I ran the test.
Key numbers to remember: Pumpkin: ~2.5g fiber/100g, ~30 calories/100g. Sweet potato: ~3g fiber/100g, ~90 calories/100g. Soluble fiber in pumpkin: ~80% of its fiber; sweet potato: ~50% soluble/50% insoluble.
The Two-Week Nalla Experiment
Here’s exactly what I did. Nalla is a 50-lb shepherd mix, so I used the common rule of thumb: 1 tablespoon of pumpkin or sweet potato per 10 lbs of body weight per meal (so 5 tablespoons total per day for her). I split that into two meals: 2.5 tablespoons per meal.
Week 1 – Pumpkin: I used plain, unsweetened canned pumpkin (make sure it’s not the pie filling with sugar and spices). I stirred it into her regular kibble. I also kept a daily log: stool quality (1-5 scale, where 1=watery, 5=perfectly firm), energy level (1-10), and pickiness (how quickly she ate her bowl). I ran a stopwatch on her eating just for fun.
Week 2 – Sweet Potato: I baked a medium sweet potato, let it cool, peeled it, and mashed it. I used the same volume (2.5 tablespoons per meal). Same logging system.
To keep it a fair test, I didn’t change anything else: same kibble, same treat schedule, same walking routine. I also made sure the stools were not caused by any other food—this was during a period when she wasn’t getting any new treats.
Data nerds, this part’s for you. Here are the week averages:
- Pumpkin week: Stool quality average: 3.8 (up from a 2.0 baseline). Efficiency: She finished her bowl in 2 minutes flat every day (she loves pumpkin). Energy: 8/10. No gas (surprising!).
- Sweet potato week: Stool quality average: 4.5 (firmer overall, but not dramatically). Pickiness: she ate it, but took 4-5 minutes to finish—she seemed indifferent. Energy: 8.5/10. Also no gas.
But here’s the twist: the first 2 days of sweet potato, her stool actually got a bit looser (down to 3.0) before firming up. That caught me off guard. Why? Possibly because the higher sugar content or the different fiber mix. But after day 3, it firmed up significantly.
I also tracked water intake—both weeks she drank about the same, so I don’t think the difference was hydration. One more observation: her coat looked slightly shinier during the sweet potato week, but that could be a placebo effect on my part.
The Results: What Fixed Nalla’s Digestion?
So which one won? In the end, sweet potato produced the firmest stools (4.5 vs 3.8), but it took longer to see results. Pumpkin was faster—her stool improved within 48 hours—but the final firmness was less impressive. For an acute case of runny poop, pumpkin wins hands-down because of the quick response. For ongoing digestive maintenance, sweet potato seemed to give a better end-state.
But here’s the kicker: when I switched back to her regular food without any additive, her stool quality returned to a 3.0—not terrible, but not great. So both ingredients were genuinely helping, just in different ways.
Why the difference? Pumpkin’s soluble fiber acts like a sponge, absorbing excess water and soothing the gut quickly. Sweet potato’s balanced fiber adds gentle bulk and feeds gut bacteria more broadly, which might explain the improved firmness after a few days. The extra calories and sugar in sweet potato might also give a slight energy boost, but they can be a downside for less active dogs.
What surprised me most was the initial loosening with sweet potato. I’m glad I tracked the data instead of giving up on day 2. Patience paid off.
How to Add Pumpkin or Sweet Potato to Your Dog’s Diet
Here are practical tips based on my experiment and common vet guidance (always check with your vet if your dog has health issues).
Pumpkin: Use plain, unsweetened canned pumpkin (not pie filling). For a 50-lb dog, start with 1 tablespoon per meal and work up to 2-3 tablespoons if needed. You can also use dried pumpkin powder—more on that below. For diarrhea, a small amount every few hours is fine, but don’t overdo it—too much can cause constipation.
Sweet potato: Bake it (no oil or salt) and peel before serving. Mash it well. For a 50-lb dog, start with 1-2 tablespoons per meal. Because it’s higher in calories, adjust your dog’s main meal accordingly. Never feed raw sweet potato—it’s hard to digest.
General rule: Start with a small amount (1/2 teaspoon for small dogs, 1 tablespoon for medium/large dogs) and increase gradually over a week. Watch for changes in stool and energy. And always introduce only one new food at a time so you can pinpoint what works.
If you’re looking for a convenient option, there are commercial products like Diggin’ Your Dog’s Firm Up Pumpkin—a fiber supplement with pumpkin and apple fiber that’s handy for travel. Or Fruitables Pumpkin Digestive Supplement, which is a gentle fiber powder you can sprinkle on food. For sweet potato fans, Davie’s Sweet Potato Dog Treats are a healthy, high-fiber chew option. And if you hate wasting half a can of pumpkin, STRELLALAB’s dried pumpkin powder lets you adjust servings per weight—no waste.
Questions I Get About Pumpkin vs. Sweet Potato
Can I give my dog sweet potato every day?
Yes, but in moderation. A small amount (1-2 tablespoons for a 50-lb dog) daily is generally safe for healthy dogs. However, because sweet potato is higher in sugar and calories than pumpkin, daily feeding should be balanced with regular food to avoid weight gain. If your dog has diabetes or other health issues, consult your vet first.
How much pumpkin should I give a dog with diarrhea?
A common starting point is 1 tablespoon per 10 lbs of body weight per meal (so 5 tablespoons for a 50-lb dog), but I’d start with half that and increase as tolerated. For acute diarrhea, you might give a small amount (1-2 teaspoons) every few hours, but if diarrhea persists beyond 24 hours, see your vet. Pumpkin helps by absorbing excess water, but it won’t fix an underlying infection or illness.
Is canned sweet potato better than canned pumpkin for dogs?
They’re different tools. Canned sweet potato offers more balanced fiber and extra nutrients, but it also has more calories and sugar. Canned pumpkin is lower in calories and has more soluble fiber, which acts faster on loose stool. The “better” choice depends on your dog’s needs: quick fix (pumpkin) or ongoing gentle support (sweet potato).
Can pumpkin or sweet potato cause constipation in dogs?
Yes, especially if you give too much. Both are high in fiber. Pumpkin’s insoluble fiber can bulk up stool too much, while sweet potato’s balanced fiber can also cause constipation if overfed. The key is moderation and always providing fresh water. If you notice hard, dry stools, reduce the amount and increase water intake.
Which has more fiber: pumpkin or sweet potato?
By weight, they’re similar—around 3g per 100g—but the type of fiber differs. Pumpkin has more soluble fiber (about 80%), while sweet potato has a balanced mix (about 50/50). Soluble fiber absorbs water and helps with diarrhea; insoluble fiber adds bulk and helps with constipation. For a dog with loose stool, pumpkin’s soluble fiber is more effective. For general digestive health, sweet potato’s blend may be more beneficial.
How do I introduce pumpkin or sweet potato to my dog’s diet?
Slowly. Start with a tiny amount (1/2 teaspoon for small dogs, 1 tablespoon for large dogs) mixed into food. Watch for any signs of upset (vomiting, gas, or change in stool). If all is well, increase every few days until you reach the desired amount. Never switch abruptly—give your dog’s gut time to adjust.
Related Recipes to Try Next
If you want to put these ingredients to work in a tasty, tummy-friendly way, try these recipes from our site—Nalla gives them two paws up:
- Pumpkin & Oat Dog Biscuits – a fiber-rich, crunchy treat
- Gut-Supportive Bone Broth & Turmeric Gelatin Squares – for extra gut support
- Chicken Bone Broth for Dogs – a 5-ingredient, gentle addition to meals
- Dog-Safe Carrot Cake Recipe – a digestible treat with a mix of veggies
How I Use Sweet Potato and Pumpkin Now
After all the data, what do I actually do? For Nalla’s everyday, I now give her a small tablespoon of sweet potato with dinner—it keeps her stools consistently firm and she seems to enjoy it (even if she takes her time). But I keep a can of pumpkin in the pantry for emergencies: if she ever has a runny-poop day, pumpkin is my first line of defense because it works fast.
If you’re looking for a convenient product, I recommend the STRELLALAB Pumpkin for Dogs powder for its easy-to-adjust servings—no half-used cans in my fridge. But as always, talk to your vet about what’s right for your pup.
What has worked for your dog’s digestion—pumpkin, sweet potato, or something else? I’d love to hear your experience at the dog park (or in the comments below).